Section 3 - Topic 1 What is a Function? 1. A group of students were discussing whether the relationship on the graph is o function Ed: The relotionship is not a function because if I craw a horizontal line at y= 2, the horizon al line crosses the graph ot two points. Debra: The relationship is a function because it is a graph of two different Alejandro: The relationship is not a function because x = 1 has two different y-values. Antoine: The relationship is a function because I can write an equation for diline. Which students are not correct and whot is the flow in their argument: