Instant replays slow down the pace of games, altering a great part of watching a game live. Furthermore, instant replay can serve as a delay for players to catch their breath or cause a team that has the momentum to cool downIn the NFL, instant replay is completely changing how catches are viewed. âPlays that would be called catches in any high school game, that people in the stadium would see as a catch, are now slowed down, replayed and frequently overturned because technically, the player slightly bobbled the ball three steps in as he hurtled to the ground at 20 miles per hour,â Jackson Hurley said.
While some NFL fans think instant replay is taking away from the game, others think it is keeping the game truthful.âI think instant replay for the NFL is a very positive thing because it keeps the game honest and keeps the refs honest too. I think the fans are less offended because all they want is the right call to be made,â said Raiders fan Aidan OâDonnell.
Most sports leagues have rules that govern when instant replay can and cannot be used. NFL coaches, for example, are allowed just two challenges per game, earning a third only if the first two are successful. If an official happens to miss more calls and those calls donât occur on plays that are automatically reviewed â scoring plays or turnovers â teams wonât be able to get the calls corrected. Coaches may challenge plays that donât require them, causing more delays while the situation is sorted out. Find- ing an effective method to regulate the replay rules is something all leagues are working on.
Fans of the NBA have mixed feelings about the instant replay rule. Some feel as if it is killing the game, others think instant replay does go far enough, and some feel that it is helping referees make the right decision during the crucial moments of a game. âThe results of the plays are a lot more accurate. In a tight game, for me, the instant replay is key,â says Anton Homeniuk.
Friend and fellow NBA fan Alex Furukawa has a different perspective. âI think instant replay is a good thing, but there are a lot of aws. For example, if a play is being reviewed and they notice something else, they canât change the call. If they are reviewing who the ball touched last, and they notice a player in the back punches another player, they canât call a foul on the player throwing punches. It also takes away from the tears and joy of the game.â
Basketball is one of the fastest paced games around, making it hard for referees to make the right call 100 percent of the time. The NBAâs instant replay rule was implemented during the 2002- 2003 playoffs. Many believe that this new rule changed the game of basketball significantly.
Since then the NBA has made various changes to the rule to enable referees to make the correct call.The league even built
its own âReplay Centerâ which has 94 monitors that play each NBA game going on at the time, from various angles. Referees in the Replay Center help make decisions for on-court reviews. The NBA canât please everyone with the replay rule. Either you enjoy watching the fast-paced games with occasional hiccups in calls, or you do not mind the reoccurring delays as long as the right call is being made.
In baseball, home-run plays and tags are subject to review, but the MLB is looking to expand to fair-or-foul calls, trapped balls, and fan interference. Already, home-run reviews add on more time to a long game. If the MLB expands to other parts of the game to review then baseball games could be slowed down dramatically. But as many know, baseball is already a slow-paced game, and fans already keep coming back through the 162 game season, instant replay may not affect them.
Allowing replays for ball and strike calls in baseball, holding penalties in football or contact under the hoop in basketball would lead to frequent stoppages. This leads to ongoing tension between those who want the use of instant replay expanded and those who donât. While instant replay has certainly changed the sports world completely, fans are still unsure if it is for the better or, for the worse. With a few more years professional leagues will eventually find a way to implement the instant replay rule, while still keeping the game honest and exciting.
