Acashier asks for your as a customer/member wants to make a return one day beyond the return window. you can make some exceptions, but too many will affect store profits.
what would you be most and least likely to do?

Explanation:

Depends.

If it has never happened before, I'd make the return, depending on what it was. If it was a screwdriver set that looked unused, I do it on my own authority.

If it was something intimate, I'd be hesitant. I'd call a supervisor.  I wouldn't do this on my own. (least likely).

If there was a policy, I'd ask what the policy said. A supervisor should know the answer to that. (most likely what I would do).

If there were a lot of returns that day, I think I'd be hesitant. I'd call for help.

answer; blank(1); /// whitelisting; blank(2); // blacklisting;

answerorganizational language;