Argument A P1: If a given animal species has a respiratory system, then that species also has a circulatory system. P2: No mammal species has a circulatory system. C: Therefore, no mammal species has a respiratory systemArgument A have at least one false premise; and it commit a fallacy. Argument A a "good" argument. Argument B P1: If a member of the Republican Party won the presidential election in 2008, then John McCain is the president of the United States. P2: A member of the Republican Party did win the presidential election in 2008. C: Therefore, John McCain is the president of the United States. Argument B have at least one false premise; and it commit a fallacy, Argument B a "good" argument.